The UK’s borders chief was unable to answer when asked by MPs to name any way in which Brexit has helped “control our borders”.
Martin Hewitt, the new border security commander, said he did “not immediately” have an answer to the question.
The pro-Brexit campaign promised that the UK could “take back control” of its borders, but since then the problem of migrants crossing the channel in small boats has soared.
As the number of crossings hit a record high last month, Donald Trump even advised Keir Starmer to “call out the military”.
Mr Hewitt, who has been in post for a year, told MPs on the Commons home affairs committee that the number of arrivals on dangerous small boats was “frustrating” and “really challenging”.
More than 36,000 people have made the perilous journey so far this year, around a third higher than the same point in 2024.
Asked if there were any examples where Brexit has helped the UK “control our borders, helped you do your job, or helped us reduce the issue of undocumented migrants”, both he and Rob Jones, director general of the National Crime Agency, who was also giving evidence to the committee, were stumped.
After a long pause Mr Hewitt told MPs: “Certainly not immediately.”
He went on to tell the committee “I will ponder on that” and said he would write to them with any answer.
Paul Kohler, the Lib Dem MP who asked the question, told Mr Hewitt he was “not surprised” by his answer.
Mr Hewitt did tell MPs, however, that he saw the potential in the government’s proposed digital ID cards, which it wants to use to tackle illegal working and deter migrants from coming to the UK.
He said: “There is no doubt that having an ability to make it significantly harder for somebody to work illegally is absolutely key. But the concept of a digital ID that makes it even harder for somebody to be in a position to try and work, I think, potentially has advantage.
“I think it’s going to be really important and I know that there is a consultation process that’s going to be begun to to work through how that could work and add value to the work that we’re doing.”
A Liberal Democrat spokesperson said: “As the Border Security Commander made clear himself, Brexit’s list of helpful achievements is precisely zero items long. We doubt this will be the last time Farage and Reform are proved wrong. It’s time the public knew about it.”
Mr Hewitt was appointed as the UK’s first Border Security Commander last September, as part of a shake-up when the new Labour government came to power.
